Skip to main content
Soccer 411
Uncategorized

GTA VI Is Here: Which PSL Clubs Won the Most Trophies Since GTA V?

From Sundowns’ second continental star to Pirates’ title return and SuperSport’s cup legacy, the GTA V-era honours compared.

GTA-era trophy comparison: Mamelodi Sundowns 21, Orlando Pirates 10, SuperSport United 5, Kaizer Chiefs 3.

Thirteen years. That is how long it took for the world to go from Grand Theft Auto V to Grand Theft Auto VI. When players first drove through Los Santos on 17 September 2013, Kaizer Chiefs were the reigning South African league champions, Pitso Mosimane was still shaping his Mamelodi Sundowns project and Orlando Pirates’ next league title was a long way off.

GTA VI arrived on 19 November 2026. That gives us an unusually entertaining way to measure an entire football era: which South African clubs collected the most major silverware while gamers waited for the next GTA? We counted league crowns, the major domestic knockout trophies and recognised continental honours. The result tells three very different stories.

The GTA V era trophy leaderboard

The top of the list belongs to Sundowns, who combined domestic consistency with genuine continental achievement. Pirates supplied the dramatic ending to a fourteen-year wait. SuperSport quietly put together a cup record that deserves more attention than it tends to receive.

Mamelodi Sundowns: the dynasty that earned its second star

Some clubs enjoy a successful season. Mamelodi Sundowns built an era. Since GTA V appeared, the Brazilians have won ten league titles, seven major domestic cups and four continental honours. The league record includes an extraordinary run of eight successive championships from 2017/18 to 2024/25.

SOCCER 411 DATA LAB · GTA V ERAMamelodi Sundowns official club badge

Mamelodi Sundowns

10League titles
7Domestic cups
4Continental honours
THE SECOND STAR

Two CAF Champions League triumphs, ten years apart.

COMPLETE HONOURS RECORD

Every trophy. Every winning season.

21 major honours between September 2013 and November 2026

CompetitionWinning years / seasons
Premiership2013/142015/162017/182018/192019/202020/212021/222022/232023/242024/25
Nedbank Cup2014/152019/202021/22
Telkom Knockout20152019
MTN820212026
CAF Champions League20162026
CAF Super Cup2017
African Football League2023

The 2026 continental title brought Sundowns their second Champions League star.

The two stars are the defining picture. In 2016, Sundowns conquered Africa under Pitso Mosimane. In May 2026, they defeated Morocco’s AS FAR 2–1 on aggregate to lift the CAF Champions League again. That second title, a decade after the first, made the achievement more than a domestic dynasty. It was a continental milestone. CAF’s account of the second star records the details.

The 2017 CAF Super Cup and 2023 African Football League added depth to that record, while the 2026 MTN8 triumph provided another domestic celebration. In a period defined by changing coaches and players, Sundowns’ ability to keep winning is arguably their biggest achievement.

Orlando Pirates: the cup kings who finally conquered the league

For much of this era, Pirates lived with a contradiction. They could turn knockout occasions into celebrations, yet the Premiership trophy kept slipping away. The Buccaneers lifted the MTN8 five times during our window, including four straight wins from 2022 to 2025, alongside three Nedbank Cups and the 2025 Carling Knockout.

SOCCER 411 DATA LAB · GTA V ERAOrlando Pirates official club badge

Orlando Pirates

1League title
9Domestic cups
0Continental honours
BACK ON TOP

The 14-year wait ended with the 2025/26 Premiership title.

COMPLETE HONOURS RECORD

Every trophy. Every winning season.

10 major honours between September 2013 and November 2026

CompetitionWinning years / seasons
Premiership2025/26
MTN820202022202320242025
Nedbank Cup2013/142022/232023/24
Carling Knockout2025

Four consecutive MTN8 titles from 2022 to 2025 preceded the league breakthrough.

Then came 23 May 2026. A 2–0 win over Orbit College clinched the 2025/26 league title and ended a fourteen-year championship drought. The official PSL report captured a result that changed how this run of trophies would be remembered.

Ten major honours is impressive. But the single league championship matters beyond the arithmetic: it transformed a side known for cup excellence into South African champions again. The rise of Pirates also gives the Soccer 411 Premiership Predictor a new question for the next campaign: can the Buccaneers sustain that level?

SuperSport United: five trophies that demand respect

South African football debates can become three-club conversations. SuperSport United’s tally is a reminder that history is bigger than the most widely supported names. They did not claim a league championship in this period. Instead, Matsatsantsa became specialists in knockout football.

SOCCER 411 DATA LAB · GTA V ERA

SuperSport United

0League titles
5Domestic cups
0Continental honours
THE CUP SPECIALISTS

Five domestic trophies, including back-to-back Nedbank Cup triumphs.

COMPLETE HONOURS RECORD

Every trophy. Every winning season.

5 major honours between September 2013 and November 2026

CompetitionWinning years / seasons
Nedbank Cup2015/162016/17
MTN820172019
Telkom Knockout2014

Their 2016 and 2017 Nedbank Cup finals were both won against Orlando Pirates.

The sequence was impressive: the 2014 Telkom Knockout, back-to-back Nedbank Cups in 2016 and 2017, then MTN8 wins in 2017 and 2019. Both Nedbank Cup finals came against Pirates. The 4–1 victory in 2017 remains one of the defining results of that run. See the Nedbank Cup’s historical final guide.

Five trophies will look modest alongside Sundowns’ 21, but that misses the point. SuperSport demonstrated how organisation, recruitment and a knack for navigating cup ties could produce a major legacy even without league dominance.

And what about Kaizer Chiefs?

The timing of the comparison is especially awkward for Chiefs. They began the GTA V era as reigning champions, won the 2014 MTN8 and the 2014/15 Premiership, but endured a prolonged wait for another major trophy. The 2025 Nedbank Cup victory over Pirates finally ended that drought. Their three honours within this window illustrate the difference between an all-time giant and success in a specific thirteen-year stretch.

It is also a reminder that trophy totals are not the only way to explain a team. How a club controlled matches, adapted to opponents and converted its chances still matters. Our feature Possession Isn’t Control explores why the scoreboard does not tell the whole tactical story.

How we counted the trophies

Our window runs from 17 September 2013 to 20 November 2026, based on the date a trophy was awarded, not when the season began. We count men’s senior first-team Premiership titles, MTN8, Nedbank Cup, Telkom Knockout and its Carling Knockout successor, CAF Champions League, CAF Super Cup and African Football League. We do not count friendly tournaments, exhibition cups, preseason invitational events, lower-division titles or youth honours. Each eligible trophy counts once. The chart highlights the four clubs discussed here, rather than pretending to be an exhaustive table of every historic Premiership club.

A league championship and a cup count equally in the numerical total, even though supporters may weigh their importance differently. That’s why every club spotlight shows its winning competitions and seasons in full. For the wider context of how we judge football performances, read How to Judge a Midfielder Without Goals and Assists.

The next GTA era starts now

Will Sundowns extend their continental legacy? Can Pirates turn one league breakthrough into another dominant spell? Which club will emerge as the next SuperSport-style cup specialist? The trophies give us an argument grounded in history. The next thirteen years will provide the answer.

What is your club’s defining achievement since September 2013? Tell us below, and tell us which trophy deserves the most weight.

Join the discussion

Which South African club will own the GTA VI era?

Make your case with trophies, performances and the competitions you value most.


Sources and editorial method: Competition histories from the PSL, CAF, Nedbank Cup and club records. GTA VI launch confirmed by Rockstar Games. Trophies counted only within the specified award-date window.